Go To MetroGuide.NetworkMetroGuide.Community Home Page
Long Island - List of Restaurants
icon

Long Island Category:
Italian

Welcome to the DiningGuide service for the Long Island area. Please select one of the listings below for a profile of a place to eat in the "Italian" category. To return to the DiningGuide Long Island home page, where you can search for restaurants in different categories, click on the "Long Island Restaurants" link, above and at the bottom of the page.

Hampton Bays Show More

75 Main
Southampton · 75 Main Street
631-283-7575 · Expensive
La Volpe Ristorante
Center Moriches · 611 Montauk Hwy.
631-874-3819 · Moderate
Serafina
East Hampton · 104 N. Main St.
631-267-3500 · Moderate
Ciao Bella Senhora
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Hampton Bays · 322 W. Montauk Hwy.
631-728-2218
Manucci's
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Montauk · 440 West Lake Drive
631-668-4455 · Moderate
Boccacini
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Hampton Bays · 42 E. Montauk Hwy.
Moderate
Fauna
Aquebogue · 720 Main Road
631-722-5813 · Moderate
Sea Cove Restaurant
Center Moriches · 361 Main St.
631-874-1071 · Moderate
The Restaurant at Four Doors Down
Mattituck · 10560 Main Road
631-298-8311 · Expensive
« Back to Top

Islip Show More

Continental Diner
North Babylon · 1143 Deer Park Ave.
631-254-1425 · Moderate
Emilio's Restaurant & Pizza
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Commack · 2201 Jericho Turnpike
631-462-6267 · Moderate
Ciao Baby Restaurant and Lounge
Commack · 204 E. Jericho Turnpike
631-543-1400 · Moderate
Gino's Tuscany
Islip · 517 Main Street
631-581-9510
La Famiglia
Smithtown · 250 W. Main St.
631-382-9454 · Moderate
La Scala
Commack · 34 Vanderbilt Parkway
631-499-6049
La Volpe Ristorante
Center Moriches · 611 Montauk Hwy.
631-874-3819 · Moderate
Mama Sbarro's
East Setauket · 238 Route 25A
631-689-8800
Mama Sbarro's Pizzeria
Hauppauge · 160 Adams Avenue
631-434-1981
Michael Anthony's Pizza
Centereach · 2425 Middle Country Rd.
631-285-7722 · Moderate
Mulberry Street
Bay Shore · 192 Howells Road
631-665-2004
Nonnina Italian Bistro
West Islip · 999 Montauk Hwy.
631-321-8717 · Expensive
Ruvo
Port Jefferson · 105 Wynn Lane
631-476-3800 · Expensive
Taormina
Commack · 34 Veterans Memorial Hwy.
631-499-6900
Tina II
Bay Shore · 635 E. Main St.
631-665-1010
Verace
Islip · 599 Main Street
631-277-3800 · Expensive
Bella Vita City Grill
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Saint James · 430-16 N. Country Rd.
631-862-8060 · Expensive
Ciao Baby
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Commack · 204 Jericho Turnpike
631-543-1400 · Expensive
Pasta Pasta
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Port Jefferson · 234 E. Main St.
631-331-5335 · Expensive
Ruvo East
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Port Jefferson · 105 Wynn Lane
631-476-3800 · Moderate
Mama Sbarro's
Hauppauge · 586 Veterans Memorial Hwy.
631-360-4343
316 East Main
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
East Setauket · 316 E. Main St.
631-689-0644 · Moderate
Nick & Gina's Pizzeria Ristorante
Selden · 638 Middle Country Rd.
631-732-3845 · Moderate
Leonardo's Pizza Cafe
Hauppauge · 656 Motor Parkway
631-234-1522
Mama Angelina's
Hauppauge · 1251 Veterans Memorial Hwy.
631-360-1463
Main Street Cafe Il Gusto Bistro Italian Cafe
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Patchogue · 30 East Main Street
631-207-6710 · Moderate
DiMaggio's Trattoria and Bar
Smithtown · 1012 W. Jericho Turnpike
631-543-6000 · Moderate
Sbarro
Bay Shore · 1701 Sunrise Hwy.
631-969-0809 · Inexpensive
Buseto
Bay Shore · 1851 Sunrise Hwy. N. Service Rd.
631-665-4939
Carrabba's
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Central Islip · 20 N. Research Pl.
631-232-1070 · Expensive
Carrabba's
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Smithtown · 730 Smithtown Bypass
631-265-1304 · Expensive
Conca D'oro Restaurant & Pizzeria
Commack · 660 Commack Road
631-499-6199 · Expensive
Il Giardino Ristorante
Commack · 6240 Jericho Turnpike
631-426-6070
Joe's Pasta & Pizza of Bay Shore
Bay Shore · 73 Howells Road
631-665-2524
Mama Sbarro's
Deer Park · 70 Deer Park Blvd.
631-254-9700
Olive Garden
Centereach · 257 Centereach Middle Country
631-585-4027 · Moderate
Puglia Of Little Italy
East Meadow · 2366 Hempstead Turnpike
516-513-1354 · Moderate
Via Italia Pizzeria & Restaurant
Commack · 118 Commack Road
631-499-4414
« Back to Top

Plainview Show More

Bel Posto
Huntington · 15 New Street
631-421-4600 · Expensive
Oevo Ristorante
Great Neck · 420 Northern Blvd.
516-504-9690 · Expensive
Palio Ristorante Jericho
Jericho · 399 Jericho Turnpike
516-433-9100 · Expensive
Seventh Street Cafe
Garden City · 126 7th Street
516-747-7575
Montana's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Freeport · 13 Atlantic Avenue
516-379-3053
Butera's
Woodbury · 7903 Jericho Turnpike
516-496-3633
Giardino - by Russo's on the Bay
Douglaston · 44 - 37 Douglaston Pkwy.
718-428-1090 · Moderate
Piccolo Mondo
Huntington Station · 1870 E. Jericho Turnpike
631-462-0718
Vintage Restaurant Bar and Grill
New Hyde Park · 2232 Jericho Turnpike
516-502-6900 · Moderate
Angelino's
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Westbury · 1 Jericho Turnpike
516-997-7333 · Inexpensive
California Pizza Kitchen
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Westbury · 1256 Old Country Rd.
516-683-3338 · Moderate
Novi - New Old Venice Inn
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Baldwin · 99 Merrick Road
516-442-4500
Olive Garden
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Westbury · 1246 Old Country Rd.
516-683-3377 · Moderate
Rose and Hunt Restaurant
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Woodbury · 7725 Jericho Turnpike
516-921-1415 · Expensive
Villa Parma Ristorante
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Syosset · 228 Jericho Turnpike
516-496-9200
La Primavera
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Hicksville · 294 South Broadway
516-938-0220
490 West
Carle Place · 490 Westbury Ave.
516-338-0848 · Expensive
A Touch of Italy
Baldwin · 1187 Grand Avenue
516-483-5119
Alletto's Restaurant
Lindenhurst · 218 Montauk Hwy.
631-226-9205 · Moderate
Amici
Massapequa · 4348 Merrick Road
516-799-4100
Angelina's Italian Cuisine
East Norwich · 1017 Oyster Bay Rd.
516-922-0033 · Moderate
Angoletto Pizzeria Restaurant
New Hyde Park · 1598 Hillside Ave.
516-358-2010
Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant
Freeport · 171 Atlantic Avenue
516-623-5645
Bella Napoli Restaurant
Farmingdale · 968 Fulton Street
516-752-0445 · Expensive
Bellissimo Ristorante Italiano
Amityville · 330 Merrick Road
631-598-0388
Benny's Ristorante
Westbury · 199 Post Avenue
516-997-8111 · Expensive
Blue Moon
Rockville Centre · 26 N. Park Ave.
516-763-4900
Cafe Al Dente
Oyster Bay · 2 Spring Street
516-922-2442
Cafe Butera
Massapequa Park · 4958 Merrick Rd.
516-795-3821
Cafe Dolce Vita
Jericho · 495 North Broadway
516-935-2233
Cafe Formaggio
Carle Place · 307 Old Country Rd.
516-333-1718
Cafe Symposio
Bellmore · 2700 Sunrise Highway
516-785-6097
Cafe Testarossa
Syosset · 499 Jericho Turnpike
516-364-8877
Cafe Toscano
Massapequa · 746 North Broadway
516-798-4500
Calagero's
Garden City · 919 Franklin Ave.
516-294-2922
Carlino's Ristorante
Mineola · 204 Jericho Turnpike
516-747-6616
Carmela's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Franklin Square · 912 Hempstead Turnpike
516-488-9898
Chi Dining Lounge
Westbury · 103 Post Avenue
516-385-3795 · Expensive
Christiano's
Syosset · 19 Ira Road
516-921-5588
Cielo Restaurant
Rockville Centre · 208 Sunrise Hwy.
516-678-1996
Cipollini Trattoria and Bar
Manhasset · 2110C Northern Blvd.
516-527-7172 · Expensive
Cirella's
Melville · 14 Broadhollow Road
631-385-7380
D'Cocco's Italian Restaurant
Oceanside · 3573 Long Beach Rd.
516-766-3938
Dodici Ristorante Italiano
Rockville Centre · 12 N. Park Ave.
516-764-3000
Eddie's Pizza
New Hyde Park · 2048 Hillside Ave.
516-354-9780
Fanatico
Jericho · 336 North Broadway
516-932-5080
Fra Amichi Pizzeria & Restaurant
Massapequa · 716 Broadway
516-799-8844
Galleria Dominick Ristorante
Westbury · 238 Post Avenue
516-997-7373
Gino's Pasta & Pizza
Baldwin · 919 Atlantic Avenue
516-546-8800
Gino's of New Hyde Park
New Hyde Park · 1113 Jericho Turnpike
516-488-1366
Harbor Mist Restaurant
Cold Spring Harbor · 105 Harbor Rd.
631-659-3888 · Moderate
IL Classico Restaurant
Massapequa Park · 4857 Merrick Rd.
516-798-8496 · Expensive
Il Mulino
Roslyn · 1042 Northern Blvd.
516-621-1870 · Expensive
Jonathans Ristorante
Huntington · 15 Wall Street
631-549-0055
La Bussola Ristorante
Glen Cove · 40 School Street
516-671-2100 · Expensive
La Pace with Chef Michael
Glen Cove · 51 Cedar Swamp Road
516-671-2970 · Expensive
La Parma Family Style Restaurant
Oceanside · 410 Merrick Road
516-763-1815
La Pizzetta
East Norwich · 1008 Oyster Bay Rd.
516-624-7800
La Spada
Huntington Station · 315 Walt Whitman Rd.
631-549-3033
La Via Pizzeria & Caterers
Freeport · 365 Atlantic Avenue
516-223-6770
La Viola
Syosset · 41 Jackson Avenue
516-364-8383
Lisa's Italian Restaurant & Pizza
Massapequa · 947 North Broadway
516-799-6189
Mama Theresa's
New Hyde Park · 2429 Jericho Turnpike
516-747-3111
Marsala Pizzeria Restaurant
Massapequa · 19 Hicksville Road
516-882-0008
Martoni's
Huntington · 1801 E. Jericho Turnpike
631-499-9133 · Moderate
Matteo's of Long Beach
Long Beach · 777 W. Beech St.
516-432-8101 · Moderate
Mio
Roslyn · 1363 Old Northern Blvd.
516-625-4223 · Expensive
Nick di Angelo
Long Beach · 152 W. Park Ave.
516-889-3366 · Moderate
Nick's
Rockville Centre · 272 Sunrise Hwy.
516-763-3278
Pasta-eria
Hicksville · 440 S. Oyster Bay Rd.
516-938-1555
Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Syosset · 265 Jericho Turnpike
516-364-6900
Piccola Bussola Ristorante
Mineola · 159 Jericho Turnpike
516-294-4260
Piccolo
Bellmore · 2770 Sunrise Highway
516-679-8787
Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington
Huntington · 215 Wall Street
631-424-5592 · Expensive
Pizzaiola
Oceanside · 3191 Long Beach Rd.
516-594-3939
Plum Tomatoes
Mineola · 228 Old Country Road
516-248-6390
Porto Vivo
Huntington · 7 Gerard Street
631-385-8486 · Moderate
Presto Pizza
Uniondale · 1144 Front Street
516-485-0161
Rachel's
Syosset · 57 Berry Hill Road
516-921-0303
Rosa's Pizza
Huntington · 313 Main Street
631-425-7694
Sal's Pizza
Rockville Centre · 285 Merrick Rd.
516-536-3594
Sazzio's Italian Kitchen
New Hyde Park · 2099 Hillside Ave.
516-739-1355
Serata
Oyster Bay · 160 Mill River Rd.
516-628-2800 · Expensive
Sole'
Oceanside · 2752 Oceanside Road
516-764-3218
Spuntino
Huntington Station · 687 Old Country Rd.
631-547-9300
Stella's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Bellmore · 2831 Merrick Road
516-826-8468
Steve's Piccola Bussola
Westbury · 649 Old Country Road
516-333-1335
Table 9
East Hills · 290 Glen Cove Road
516-625-9099 · Expensive
Umberto's
New Hyde Park · 633 Jericho Turnpike
516-437-7698
Vero - Cibo - Vino - Liquori Bar
Amityville · 192 Broadway
631-608-4340 · Moderate
Via Roma
Merrick · 1764 Merrick Avenue
516-868-2311
Villa Milano
Manhasset · 168 Plandome Road
516-365-3440
Vincent's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Baldwin · 919 Atlantic Avenue
516-379-2020
Vinny's Pizza & Pasta
Bellmore · 2719 Merrick Road
516-221-5389
Wander Inn
Baldwin · 2880 Grand Avenue
516-223-5925
Almarco Italian Grill
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Huntington · 13 Wall Street
631-935-1690
Angelina's II
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Syosset · 30 Berry Hill Road
516-364-8234
Barolo Restaurant
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Melville · 1197 Walt Whitman Rd.
631-421-3750 · Expensive
Boccaccio Restaurant
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Hicksville · 275 W. Old Country Rd.
516-433-6262 · Moderate
Butera's
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Massapequa Park · 4964 Merrick Rd.
516-795-1929
Cafe Rustica
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Great Neck · 200 Middle Neck Rd.
516-829-6464 · Moderate
Ciao Baby
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Massapequa Park · 5074 Sunrise Hwy.
516-799-5200 · Moderate
Circa Ristorante Enoteca
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Mineola · 348 E. Jericho Turnpike
516-280-2234 · Moderate
Grasso's
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Cold Spring Harbor · 134 Main St.
631-367-6060 · Moderate
Luce
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
East Norwich · 1053 Oyster Bay Rd.
516-624-8330 · Expensive
Matteo's Family Style Ristorante Italiano
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Huntington Station · 300 W. Jericho Turnpike
631-421-6001
Mill Pond House
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Centerport · 437 Route 25 A
631-261-7663 · Moderate
Novita Wine Bar & Trattoria
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Garden City · 860 Franklin Ave.
516-739-7660 · Expensive
Francesca's Restaurant
Plainview · 595 Old Country Rd.
516-681-0200
Gino's Pizza
Uniondale · 428 Uniondale Ave.
516-481-3233
Joanina
Huntington · 35 Gerard Street
631-549-2727
Prince Umberto
Wantagh · 1910 Wantagh Avenue
615-221-7823
Massaro's Restaurant Pizzeria & Caterers
Mineola · 106 Mineola Boulevard
516-747-2129
Osteria da Nino
Huntington · 292 Main Street
631-425-0820
Mr Miceli Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Rockville Centre · 19 N. Park Ave.
516-764-7701
Cafe Bacci
Westbury · 1636 Old Country Rd.
516-832-8888
Gigi's Pizza
New Hyde Park · 673 Hillside Ave.
516-326-7879
Gianni's Pizza & Pasta
Rockville Centre · 40 N. Village Ave.
516-763-9600
Lia's Pizzeria Cucina Italiana
Oceanside · 60 Atlantic Avenue
516-764-4971
Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Massapequa · 820 Hicksville Rd.
516-798-8666
Romano's Macaroni Grill
Westbury · 1195 Corporate Drive
516-683-8611
Sbarro
Melville · 401 Broadhollow Road
631-715-4100 · Inexpensive
Bella Notte
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Syosset · 98 Jackson Avenue
516-364-2090 · Moderate
Abela's Pizzeria Restaurant
Oceanside · 396 Merrick Road
516-256-0770
Bertucci's Brick Oven Pizzeria
Melville · 881 Walt Whitman Rd.
631-427-9700 · Inexpensive
Bobby Basil
Franklin Square · 183 Franklin Ave.
516-775-9878
Bocca di rosa
Great Neck · 24 Middle Neck Rd.
516-487-9169
Broadway Pizza & Catering
Greenlawn · 60 Greenlawn Broadway
631-261-0828
Brooklyn Cafe
Bellmore · 505 Bedford Avenue
516-679-3661
Cafe Positano
Hempstead · 119 Jerusalem Ave.
516-505-2500
Cafe Rossini
Mineola · 106 Main Street
516-877-7850
Caffe Baldo
Wantagh · 2849 Jerusalem Avenue
516-785-4780
Caffe Classico Ristorante
Great Neck · 76 Middle Neck Rd.
516-829-8008
Carmela's Italian Restaurant
Massapequa · 4151 Merrick Road
516-799-1871
Centurion Pizza
Garden City · 279 Nassau Blvd. S.
516-486-1550
Ciao Restaurant
Oceanside · 3451 Long Beach Rd.
516-766-9099 · Moderate
Cinellis
Franklin Square · 1195 Hempstead Turnpike
516-352-2204
Cinellis
Oceanside · 156 Davidson Avenue
516-678-9494
Cristina's
Roslyn · 1221 Old Northern Blvd.
516-625-2700 · Moderate
Cugini Pizzeria & Restaurant
Plainview · 1048 Old Country Rd.
516-931-3910
Cugini Pizzeria & Restaurant
Mineola · 432 Jericho Turnpike
516-248-7770
Dante's Pizza
Hicksville · 285 South Broadway
516-932-0678
Di Carlos Pizza & Pasta
Mineola · 100 Herricks Road
516-248-0080
Fabio's
Merrick · 2035 Merrick Road
516-378-2323
Fianona
New Hyde Park · 1635 Hillside Ave.
516-437-6655
Gino's of Huntington
Huntington · 75 E. Main St.
631-425-7437
Guidos
Huntington · 245 Main Street
631-424-3301
La Famiglia
Plainview · 641 Old Country Rd.
516-938-2050
La Mia Pizza
Freeport · 42 South Main Street
516-377-1700
La Vera Pizzeria & Restaurant
New Hyde Park · 2085 Hillside Ave.
516-355-2279
Lucca
Bellmore · 2520 Merrick Road
516-221-1717
Luigi's Italian Cuisine
Melville · 672 Walt Whitman Rd.
631-673-1766
MaMa Sofia's
Hicksville · 357 South Broadway
516-681-6267
Mama Theresa's
Westbury · 399 Old Country Road
516-334-3334
Mario's Pizza & Restaurant
Oceanside · 2822 Brower Avenue
516-536-5460
Matteo's Family Style Ristorante Italiano
Bellmore · 416 Bedford Avenue
516-409-1779
Napoli Pizza & Restaurant
Great Neck · 116 Northern Blvd.
516-487-8435
Olive Garden
Massapequa · 5598 Sunrise Hwy.
516-797-1604 · Moderate
Rigatoni Restaurant
Rockville Centre · 27 N. Park Ave.
516-678-2595
Sal D's of Huntington
Huntington · 208 Wall Street
631-549-0643
Sergio's Italian Restaurant
Massapequa Park · 5014 Merrick Rd.
516-541-6554
Stresa East Italian Restaurant
Woodbury · 7940 Jericho Turnpike
516-364-1565
Valentino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
New Hyde Park · 2458 Jericho Turnpike
516-742-9434
Viajo's Pizza & Pasta
Huntington Station · 1277 E. Jericho Turnpike
631-425-0068
Victor's
Melville · 712 Walt Whitman Rd.
631-351-1270
Villa Margherita Italian Restaurant
New Hyde Park · 2098 Hillside Ave.
516-746-8323
Il Faro Restaurant Bar
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Baldwin · 807 Atlantic Avenue
516-378-4365
Sbarro
Huntington Station · 260-9 Route 110
631-424-0900 · Inexpensive
Sbarro
Massapequa · 479 Sunrise Mall
516-795-6409 · Inexpensive
Caprio's Brick Oven Pizza Restaurant
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Franklin Square · 691 Hempstead Turnpike
516-505-1604
Sbarro
Hicksville · Route 106/107
516-935-9818 · Inexpensive
Franina's Italian Cuisine
Reader rating: 1.0 out of 5
Syosset · 58 Jericho Turnpike
516-496-9770 · Expensive
Il Felice
Reader rating: 1.0 out of 5
Seaford · 3943 Merrick Road
516-809-5860 · Moderate
La Casuccia
Reader rating: 1.0 out of 5
Farmingdale · 196 Main Street
516-249-0140
Silver Pheasant
Reader rating: 1.0 out of 5
Lindenhurst · 216 W. Montauk Hwy. (State Rd. 27A)
631-957-3580 · Moderate
Spinelli's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reader rating: 1.0 out of 5
Greenlawn · 763 Pulaski Road
631-261-4202
« Back to Top
ADV: Buy event tickets online!
Icon Legend:
Cost Legend (Average Price/Person):
Reader Rating Legend:
Editor Rating Legend:
DiningGuide New York
DiningGuide AlbanyDiningGuide BuffaloDiningGuide ElmiraDiningGuide RochesterDiningGuide Syracuse
DiningGuide HartfordDiningGuide Newark

MN logo© 1996-2018MetroGuide, Inc. | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions

DiningGuide, DiningGuide.Network, DiningGuide.Community and DiningGuide Long Island are service marks of MetroGuide.com, Inc.

To submit your restaurant, please use the: DiningG.U.I.-de.
To contact us at MetroGuide: Click Here.

Islip RestaurantsPlainview RestaurantsHampton Bays RestaurantsNew York City Restaurants