Research Long Island restaurants and reviews with......DiningGuide Long IslandHomeAboutContact
Long Island - List of RestaurantsGo to MetroGuide.CommunityMetroGuide.Network Home Page

DiningGuide Long Island:
Seafood

Welcome to the DiningGuide service for the Long Island area. Please select one of the listings below for a profile of a place to eat in the "Seafood" category. To return to the DiningGuide Long Island home page, where you can search for restaurants in different categories, click on the "Long Island Restaurants" link, above and at the bottom of the page.

Hampton Bays

Plaza Cafe
Southampton · 61 Hill Street
631-283-9323 · Expensive
Seafood Barge
Southold · 62980 Main Road
631-765-3010 · Expensive
Second House Tavern
Montauk · 161 Second House Road
631-688-2877 · Expensive
Trata
Water Mill · 1020 Montauk Hwy.
631-726-6200 · Expensive
Cyril's Fish House
Amagansett · 2167 Montauk Hwy.
631-267-7993 · Inexpensive
Reader rating: 3.8 out of 5
Restaurant Blue
Blue Point · 7 Montauk Highway
631-363-6666 · Moderate
Reader rating: 4.1 out of 5
Manucci's
Montauk · 440 West Lake Drive
631-668-4455 · Moderate
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
The Lobster Roll
Amagansett · 1980 Montauk Hwy.
631-267-3740 · Inexpensive
Reader rating: 4.5 out of 5
Indian Cove Restaurant and Marina
Hampton Bays · 258 E. Montauk Hwy.
631-728-5366 · Moderate
Reader rating: 1.6 out of 5
21 Water Restaurant
Sag Harbor · 21 W. Water St.
631-725-7500 · Expensive
Arthur Treacher's
Shirley · 351 William Floyd Pkwy.
631-281-1338
Blue Parrott Bar & Grill
East Hampton · 33A Main Street
631-324-3609 · Moderate
Chequit Inn
Shelter Island · 23 Grand Ave.
631-749-0018 · Expensive
Dave's Grill
Montauk · 468 West Lake Drive
631-668-9190 · Expensive
Palm Restaurant
East Hampton · 94 Main Street
631-324-0411 · Expensive
The Lakeside
Montauk · 183 Edgemere Street
631-668-3455 · Inexpensive
Clam Bar At Napeague
Amagansett · 2025 Montauk Hwy.
631-267-6348 · Inexpensive
Reader rating: 1.6 out of 5
« Back to Top

Islip

H2O Seafood Grill
Smithtown · 215 W. Main St.
631-361-6464 · Expensive
The Fifth Season
Port Jefferson · 34 E. Broadway
631-477-8500 · Moderate
Bonwit Inn
Commack · 1 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy.
631-499-2068 · Moderate
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Snapper Inn
Oakdale · 464 Shore Drive
631-589-0248 · Moderate
Reader rating: 2.8 out of 5
The Village Way
Port Jefferson · 106 Main St.
631-928-3395 · Moderate
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
Arthur Treacher's
East Islip · 126 Montauk Hwy.
631-581-1141
Catfish Annie's
Commack · 116 Commack Road
631-499-5131
Jeff's Seafood & Galley
East Northport · 1965 Jericho Turnpike
631-858-2393 · Inexpensive
Long Island Grill
Lake Ronkonkoma · 200 Portion Rd.
631-981-7893 · Expensive
Oysterman's Restaurant & Pub
Sayville · 45 Foster Avenue
631-589-7775 · Expensive
White Cap Fish
Islip · 130 Montauk Highway
631-581-0125
Red Lobster
Stony Brook · 2220 Nesconset Hwy.
631-689-9060 · Moderate
« Back to Top

Plainview

56th Fighter Group
East Farmingdale · One Route 110
631-694-8280 · Moderate
Aqua - Underwater Grill and Wine Bar
Rockville Centre · 242 Sunrise Hwy.
516-766-7662 · Moderate
Burton & Doyle Steakhouse
Great Neck · 661 Northern Blvd.
516-487-9200 · Expensive
George Martin's Coastal Grill
Long Beach · 40 E. Park Ave.
516-432-2690 · Expensive
Legal Sea Foods
Huntington Station · 160 Walt Whitman Rd.
631-271-9777 · Moderate
Legal Sea Foods Garden City
Garden City · 630 Old Country Rd.
516-248-4600 · Expensive
Limani
Roslyn · 1043 Northern Blvd.
516-869 8989 · Expensive
Nautilus Cafe
Freeport · 46 Woodcleft Avenue
516-379-2566 · Expensive
Wild Fin
Huntington · 368 New York Ave.
631-549-5757 · Expensive
Blackstone Steakhouse
Melville · 10 Pinelawn Road
631-271-7780 · Expensive
Reader rating: 3.9 out of 5
Angelino's
Westbury · 1 Jericho Turnpike
516-997-7333 · Inexpensive
Reader rating: 2.3 out of 5
Bryant & Cooper Steakhouse
Roslyn · 2 Middle Neck Road
516-627-7270 · Expensive
Reader rating: 3.0 out of 5
B. K. Sweeney's Steak House
Garden City · 636 Franklin Ave.
516-746-3075 · Moderate
Bidgelow's Seafood
Oceanside · 79 N. Long Branch Rd.
516-678-3878
Bistro Saint German
Mineola · 149 Mineola Boulevard
516-699-9000 · Moderate
Black Sea
Oceanside · 2825 Long Beach Rd.
516-992-1742
Brasas Del Mar
Freeport · 80 Church Street
516-546-6023
Brooklyn Fish And Chicken
Amityville · 524 Broadway
631-789-6522
Bruzell's Restaurant
Great Neck · 451 Middle Neck Rd.
516-482-6600 · Moderate
Floxy's Seafood Basket
Uniondale · 957 Nassau Road
516-489-3959
Grand Slammin Fish & Chips
Baldwin · 1847 Grand Avenue
516-223-3503
Jackson Landing
Bellmore · 2565 Bellmore Avenue
516-785-5353 · Expensive
La Union Fish And Chips
Uniondale · 624 Jerusalem Ave.
516-505-0627
Legal Sea Foods
Huntington Station · 160 Walt Whitman Rd.
631-271-9777 · Expensive
Long Island Fish & Chips
Massapequa · 925 North Broadway
516-541-5161
Red Fish Grill
Plainview · 430 Woodbury Road
516-932-8460
Red Lobster
Hicksville · One Nevada Street
516-822-8393 · Moderate
Red Lobster
Baldwin · 684 Sunrise Highway
516-546-0022 · Moderate
Southside Fish & Calm
Lindenhurst · 395 W. Montauk Hwy.
631-226-3322
The Jolly Fisherman
Roslyn · 25 Main Street
516-621-0055
Uncle Bacala's Italian Seafood & More
New Hyde Park · 2370 Jericho Turnpike
516-739-0505
Red Lobster
Carle Place · 211-217 Old Country Rd.
516-248-7411 · Moderate
« Back to Top
ADV: Buy event tickets online!
Reader Rating Legend:
  Poor
  Fair
  Average
  Good
  Excellent
Editor Rating Legend:
  Poor
  Fair
  Average
  Good
  Excellent
DiningGuide New York
DiningGuide Albany, New YorkDiningGuide BuffaloDiningGuide Rochester, New YorkDiningGuide Syracuse
DiningGuide HartfordDiningGuide Newark

Write Reviews ···> Earn Rewards Points
Write restaurant reviews and earn points that can be redeemed for great prizes.
Click Here For A Free Membership

© 1996-2009, MetroGuide, Inc. | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions

DiningGuide, DiningGuide.Network, DiningGuide.Community and DiningGuide Long Island are service marks of MetroGuide.com, Inc.

To submit your restaurant, please use the: DiningG.U.I.-de.
To contact us at MetroGuide: Click Here.